Rice University logo
 
Top blue bar image
A Graduate Student's Research Website
 

Archive for December, 2011


“Likely Voters” Lie

December 15th, 2011 by James

Interesting if not particularly surprising piece about the difficulty of screening “likely” vs. non-voters (see here).  I also liked the peek inside campaign polling vs. public polling.  The most interesting piece of data was likely that “non-voting” respondents to the likely voter screen still tend to turnout at relatively high rates.  Of course, it takes the author the length of the article to get to the concept that people are expressing their dissatisfaction with the “system” or the slate of candidates, rather than whether or not they’ll actually vote.

Which brings up the point of calling these people “liars.”  I mean, it’s laying a normative judgement on top of what is a psychological process. When the respondents say “I’m not voting,” they likely really mean it at that moment.  Later post-hoc justification, an “epiphany” about a particular candidate, simple social pressure, all these drive them to turnout.  I’m not expecting a detailed discussion of political psychology, but it’s a little harsh to call them “liars,” although admittedly it’s decent headline writing and an overall good piece of journalism.

New Report Says Term Limits Detrimental to Missouri Legislature

December 13th, 2011 by James

Just a quick re-post from “The Ticket”, the state leg blog.  Basically, term limits are bad for legislatures, representation, etc.  Basically, detrimental to democracy all around (see here).  This is one of my favorite examples of how some folks can still support a position after it’s been empirically shown to be detrimental and satisfy none of their justifying conditions.  The literature is pretty consistent: term limits are a bad idea.  And yet, a la Rick Perry, the idea still gets tossed around, even by people that ought to know better.  Which may or may not include Perry.